How to choose an electric fireplace insert
Measure three numbers. Take the inside width, the inside height and the depth from the front edge to the back of the opening. The insert has to clear all three. Insert sizes are named for the opening they are built for, so a 23-inch insert goes into furniture made for a 23-inch insert. That is the most common size in fireplace furniture, which is why 7 of our 12 inserts are 23 inches.
Check depth for shallow furniture. Slim TV stands and mantel cabinets leave little room behind the glass. Two of ours list a body depth of just 5.15 inches, and three more ship in a carton only 6.93 inches deep.
For an existing wood fireplace, skip the framing. A log-set insert sits on the hearth floor inside the opening and plugs into a 120 V outlet. Close the damper so warm room air does not go up the chimney.
Heat is close across the range. A 1,400 W insert puts out about 4,777 BTU and costs about 24¢ an hour at about 17¢ per kWh. The 1,500 W infrared quartz models put out about 5,118 BTU, roughly 7% more, for about 25.5¢ an hour. Most of them also run the flame with the heat off.
Then decide how real it should look. A realistic electric fireplace insert usually comes down to the bed and the back wall: resin logs, a brick-tile back, an ember bed that glows on its own, or multiple flame colors.
| Your opening | Insert size | What we carry | Heater |
|---|---|---|---|
| About 18 in wide, shallow | 18 in | Small insert with brick look, 5.15 in deep | 1,400 W |
| Open masonry fireplace | 21 in log set | Log insert that sits on the hearth | 1,500 W infrared |
| About 23 in wide | 23 in | 7 models: log set, slim, brick and logs, 4 flame colors, replacement, smart, TV stand insert | 1,400 to 1,500 W |
| About 26 in wide | 26 in | Log set with separate ember glow | 1,400 W |
| About 28 in wide | 28 in | Log set with 1 to 9 hour timer | 1,400 W |
| About 33 in wide | 33 in | Our widest log set | 1,400 W |
If your opening falls between two sizes, send us the three measurements before you order and we will check the fit with you.
Which one is right for you?
- An electric fireplace insert for an existing fireplace: the 21" log insert needs no install. Set it on the hearth and plug it in.
- A shallow TV stand or stove cabinet: the 18" small insert is 5.15 inches deep and still runs 1,400 W.
- The most lifelike flame: the 23" infrared insert has 4 flame colors, 5 ember levels and a tiled surround.
- An older fireplace console: the 23" replacement insert is sold as a swap for furniture bought from 2000 to 2020.
- A wide mantel: the 33" ultra-thin insert gives you our longest log set.
Need the furniture too? Browse fireplace TV stands or electric fireplaces with mantel.
Frequently asked questions
How do you install an electric fireplace insert?
Most of ours are plug-in models. Set the insert in the opening, secure it as the manual shows, and run the cord to a standard outlet. No gas line or vent. Our step-by-step insert installation guide covers furniture, framed walls and existing hearths.
Do electric fireplace inserts give off real heat?
Yes. A 1,400 W insert puts out about 4,777 BTU and a 1,500 W insert about 5,118 BTU. Manufacturers rate most of ours for supplemental heat in rooms up to 400 sq ft. That warms the room you are in. It will not replace a furnace.
Do electric fireplace inserts need to be vented?
No. Nothing burns, so there is no exhaust. Leave the insert's own air vents clear and follow the clearances in its manual.
Can I put an electric insert in my existing fireplace?
Yes. The simplest route is a log-set insert that sits on the hearth floor and plugs into an outlet near the fireplace. Close the damper to stop drafts. If your outlet is far from the hearth, have an electrician add one rather than running an extension cord.
How deep is an electric fireplace insert?
It depends on the model. Our 18-inch and one 23-inch insert list a body depth of 5.15 inches. Several others ship in cartons under 7 inches deep. Check each product page and compare it with the depth of your opening.
Are electric fireplace inserts worth it?
If you have a dead fireplace or a console with a broken insert, most of ours sell for under $350 and give you a working flame plus supplemental heat with no chimney cleaning. See our picks in best electric fireplace inserts.