Free shipping to the lower 48 states on every order

Not sure what fits? Take the 60-second fireplace finder

Electric fireplaces need no chimney or vent. Here is why

Best Electric Fireplace Inserts: Honest Picks by Need

We sell every insert on this list, so we kept it to published specs: size, watts, flame settings, controls and listed certification. Here's which one fits which job, and what to check before you buy any insert.

Electric fireplace insert with a log set and orange flame glowing inside a white brick fireplace
In this guide 10 sections
  1. How we chose
  2. The picks at a glance
  3. Best value: 23-inch ultra-thin insert
  4. Best for small openings: 21-inch infrared log set
  5. Most realistic flame: 23-inch infrared insert with tile surround
  6. Quietest and infrared: what the specs can and can't tell you
  7. Best app control: 23-inch Bluetooth insert
  8. Best for larger openings: 26, 28 and 33-inch inserts
  9. What to look for in any electric fireplace insert
  10. FAQ

Full disclosure: we sell every insert on this page. That’s why we kept it to what the listings actually say and told you where a spec is missing or contradicts itself.

How we chose

We compared the published specs for the inserts we carry: nominal size, heater wattage, listed heating area, flame and brightness settings, timer range, thermostat range, controls and the certification the manufacturer lists. We checked these listings in November 2026.

What we didn’t do: run lab tests, measure noise or collect reviews. Our store doesn’t have customer reviews yet, and we’re not going to invent star ratings. Prices change daily as our suppliers update them, so we give ranges and you’ll see the current price on each product page.

The picks at a glance

Best for Insert Heater Flame and controls Listed certification
Best value, standard 23-inch openings 23-inch ultra-thin insert 1,400 W, up to 400 sq ft 4 brightness settings, 64 to 82°F thermostat, 1 to 8 hour timer, remote CSA/UL
Small openings 21-inch infrared log set 1,500 W infrared quartz, up to 400 sq ft 4 brightness settings, 1 to 9 hour timer, remote CSA/UL
Most traditional look 23-inch infrared insert with tile surround 1,500 W infrared quartz, up to 400 sq ft 4 flame colors, 5 brightness levels, 1 to 9 hour timer CSA/UL
Brick-back infrared 23-inch infrared quartz with brick 1,500 W infrared quartz, up to 400 sq ft Resin logs, 4 brightness settings, 0.5 to 6 hour timer CSA/UL
App control 23-inch Bluetooth and app insert Listed two ways (see below) App and remote, 3 brightness settings, 1 to 6 hour timer ETL
Larger openings 26, 28 and 33-inch ultra-thin inserts 1,400 W, up to 400 sq ft Flame and ember bed run separately, 1 to 8 or 9 hour timer CSA/UL

Best value: 23-inch ultra-thin insert

The 23-inch ultra-thin insert is the one we’d point most people to first. 23 inches is the most common firebox size in TV stands and media consoles, and this model covers the basics without extras you might not use: a 1,400 W heater rated for supplemental heat up to 400 sq ft, 11 thermostat settings from 64 to 82°F, a 1 to 8 hour timer, four flame brightness settings and a remote. The manufacturer lists CSA/UL certification and two layers of protection, an overheat cutoff and a fuse.

Skip it if you want a deep log set or a tile back panel. This is a slim insert built for furniture.

Replacing a firebox in an older TV stand? The 23-inch replacement insert has nearly the same specs and the maker lists it for recessing in a wall or furniture, and pitches it as a swap for consoles bought between 2000 and 2020.

Best for small openings: 21-inch infrared log set

The 21-inch 3D log set insert is our smallest standard pick and, unusually for its size, runs a 1,500 W infrared quartz heater. It has a flat bottom, so it sits on the floor of an existing firebox, and the maker says the log set is designed for most existing fireplace openings. Four brightness settings, a 1 to 9 hour timer and a remote. CSA/UL listed per the manufacturer.

Skip it if your opening is a shallow cabinet cutout. A log set runs deeper than a slim insert, so check the listed depth against yours.

Most realistic flame: 23-inch infrared insert with tile surround

Realism is partly taste, so here’s how we judged it on paper: more control over the flame, a real log set and a back panel that looks like a fireplace. The 23-inch infrared insert scores best on all three. It offers four flame colors and five brightness levels for the ember bed, a log set and a faux tile surround. It also runs 1,500 W infrared quartz heat and a 1 to 9 hour timer.

If you prefer the look of brick, the 23-inch infrared insert with brick pairs resin logs with a brick-pattern back and four brightness settings. Its timer runs 0.5 to 6 hours.

Skip these if you need the thinnest insert possible. Both are deeper than the ultra-thin models.

Quietest and infrared: what the specs can and can’t tell you

None of the inserts we sell publishes a decibel rating, so we can’t honestly name the quietest one. Anyone who does should be able to show you a number.

Here’s what we can say. In flame-only mode the heater is off, so the fan noise most people notice goes away. Every insert on this list runs flame-only. If quiet matters most, for a bedroom or a home office, use flame-only and let your main heat do the work.

The three infrared quartz models (the 21-inch log set and both 23-inch infrared inserts) are all 1,500 W. The makers say infrared quartz heat helps keep natural humidity in the air. The listings don’t say they’re quieter, so we won’t either.

Best app control: 23-inch Bluetooth insert

The 23-inch Bluetooth and app insert is the one to look at if you want to run your fireplace from your phone. It also has a remote, a flame-only mode, three flame brightness settings, a 62 to 82°F heat range and a 1 to 6 hour timer. The manufacturer lists ETL certification.

Two honest notes. The listing gives two different heat figures: 5,000 BTU for 400 sq ft in the title and 4,760 BTU for 300 sq ft in the description. Plan on the lower one. And its stock comes and goes with our supplier, so check the product page before you plan around it.

Best for larger openings: 26, 28 and 33-inch inserts

If your opening is wider than 23 inches, a bigger insert fills it better than trim does. Our 26-inch, 28-inch and 33-inch ultra-thin inserts share the same core: 1,400 W heat for up to 400 sq ft, 11 thermostat settings from 64 to 82°F, a flame and ember bed you can run separately, and CSA/UL certification listed by the maker. The 26-inch has a 1 to 8 hour timer and four brightness settings. The 28 and 33-inch have 1 to 9 hour timers. The 33-inch listing mentions both three and four brightness settings, so assume three.

What to look for in any electric fireplace insert

  • Fit first. Measure front width, rear width, height and depth, and buy to the smallest number. Our guide on how to measure for an electric fireplace insert has a size chart.
  • Heat output. Most plug-in inserts run 1,400 W or 1,500 W. That’s supplemental heat for one room, not a furnace replacement.
  • Flame controls. Brightness levels, flame colors and an ember bed that runs on its own make more difference than marketing words like “3D.”
  • Thermostat and timer. A thermostat holds the room where you set it. A timer means you can fall asleep without worrying about it.
  • Listed certification. Look for a CSA, UL or ETL listing named on the product page, plus overheat protection.
  • Power. A standard 120V plug. Plan on a wall outlet in or near the firebox, never an extension cord.

What the heater costs to run

Heater setting Heat output Cost per hour at about 17¢ per kWh
1,400 W about 4,777 BTU about 24¢
1,500 W about 5,118 BTU about 26¢

The 100 W difference works out to about 2¢ an hour. Pick on fit and flame, not on that.

FAQ

What is the best electric fireplace insert?

The one that fits your opening, heats the room you have and has a flame you like looking at. For a standard 23-inch opening, we’d start with a 1,400 W slim insert with a log set, a thermostat, a timer and a listed certification. For bigger openings, size up rather than filling the gap with trim.

Are electric fireplace inserts worth it?

For an unused wood fireplace or an empty TV stand firebox, usually yes. You get flame you can run all year, supplemental heat for one room, no venting and no ash. They won’t heat a whole house, and they won’t match the warmth of a roaring wood fire.

Do electric fireplace inserts give off heat?

Yes. The inserts on this page run 1,400 W or 1,500 W heaters, roughly 4,777 to 5,118 BTU, rated by the makers for supplemental heat up to about 400 sq ft. More on that in our guide on whether electric fireplaces give off heat.

How much is an electric fireplace insert?

Our inserts run roughly $150 to $350, depending on size and features, and prices move with our suppliers. Shipping is free to the lower 48 states. Larger, deeper or app-controlled inserts sit toward the top of that range.

How does an electric fireplace insert work?

LED lights behind a screen and a log set create the flame effect, and a separate fan-forced heater (or infrared quartz element) warms the room. The two run independently, so you can have flame with no heat in summer. It plugs into a standard 120V outlet and needs no chimney or vent.

Not sure which one fits? Browse all our electric fireplace inserts, or send us your measurements and we’ll narrow it down.

Written by The Fireplace Co. team

We write our guides from manufacturer specs and published safety standards, and update them when specs change. Spotted something out of date, or need help with your room? Ask us.

Free shipping

To the lower 48 states, on every order

No vent or gas line

Most models plug into a standard outlet

Not sure which one fits?
Find your fireplace in about a minute
Four quick questions about your room and TV, and you get a shortlist that fits.
Try the Fireplace Finder
The Fireplace Co.
Welcome offer
Take 10% off your first order
Sizing tips, new arrivals and early sale access. Your code appears as soon as you sign up.
Get my 10% code
One code per customer. No spam, unsubscribe any time.
No thanks
Welcome offer
Take 10% off your first order
Sizing tips, new arrivals and early sale access.
Get my 10% code
One code per customer. No spam, unsubscribe any time.
No thanks